Press "Enter" to skip to content

American Idyll: Academic Antielitism as Cultural Critique by Catherine Liu

By Catherine Liu

“We are actually supposedly in a postracial second, with an African American president who got here of highbrow age within the Nineteen Eighties, but if we're to totally confront the altering face of schooling and politics during this period of perpetual battle, fiscal decline, and virulent ‘authoritarian populist’ Tea social gathering dissent, it is vital to start unraveling our contemporary heritage. Catherine Liu deals a compelling polemic for liberalism—a soiled be aware for Sixties New Leftists and Nineties neoconservatives alike—and any publication that annoys those poles certainly has a lot going for it. Bringing her significant wisdom of severe concept approximately movie, literature, media, and philosophy to endure in this ancient challenge through linking developments inside supposedly left/liberal humanities scholarship to the discourse of conservative punditry, American Idyll is not anything lower than brilliant.”—Paula Rabinowitz, writer, Modernism, Inc.

A trenchant critique of failure and opportunism around the political spectrum, American Idyll argues that social mobility, as soon as a respected hallmark of yank society, has ebbed, as better schooling has turn into a mechanistic method for effective sorting that has extra to do with classification formation than anything. educational freedom and aesthetic schooling are reserved for high-scoring, privileged scholars and vocational schooling is your best option for economically marginal ones.

Throughout so much of yank historical past, antielitist sentiment used to be reserved for assaults opposed to an entrenched aristocracy or rapacious plutocracy, however it has now turn into a rebellion opposed to meritocracy itself, directed opposed to what insurgents see as a ruling type of credentialed elites with levels from particular educational associations. Catherine Liu finds that, in the academy and stemming from the rather new self-discipline of cultural stories, animosity opposed to services has lively a lot of the Left’s cultural criticism.

By unpacking the disciplinary formation and educational goals of yank cultural stories, Liu uncovers the family tree of the present antielitism, putting the populism that dominates headlines inside a wide old context. within the technique, she emphasizes the relevance of the historic origins of populist rebel opposed to finance capital and its political effect. American Idyll unearths the not likely alliance among American pragmatism and proponents of the Frankfurt institution and argues for the significance of large frames of ancient considering in encouraging powerful educational debate inside of democratic associations. In a daring idea scan that revives and defends Richard Hofstadter’s theories of anti-intellectualism in American lifestyles, Liu asks, What if cultural populism were the consensus politics of the prior 3 decades?

American Idyll indicates that fresh antielitism does not anything to redress the resource of its discontent—namely, transforming into fiscal inequality and diminishing social mobility. as an alternative, pseudopopulist rage, in conservative and countercultural varieties alike, has been reworked into resentment, content material purely to take down allegedly elitist cultural types with no wondering the genuine political and monetary consolidation of powers that has taken position in the USA up to now thirty years.

Show description

Read or Download American Idyll: Academic Antielitism as Cultural Critique PDF

Similar politics books

Dispossession: The Performative in the Political

Dispossession describes the situation of these who've misplaced land, citizenship, estate, and a broader belonging to the area. This thought-provoking ebook seeks to complex our figuring out of dispossession outdoor of the traditional good judgment of ownership, a trademark of capitalism, liberalism, and humanism.

The Red Flag: How Communism Changed the World

Communism was once the most robust political and highbrow pursuits of the trendy global; on the peak in their effect Communist regimes managed greater than a 3rd of the earth's floor. Given its quick upward push and vast achieve, its unexpected and thoroughly unexpected cave in after 1989 turns out the entire extra spectacular and wanting clarification.

We Are Doomed: Reclaiming Conservative Pessimism

To his fellow conservatives, John Derbyshire makes a plea: Don't be seduced through this nonsense approximately "the politics of wish. " Skepticism, pessimism, and suspicion of chuffed speak are the genuine features of an authentically conservative temperament. And from Hobbes and Burke via Lord Salisbury and Calvin Coolidge, as much as Pat Buchanan and Mark Steyn in our personal time, those ideals have saved the human race from blindly chasing its utopian goals correct off a cliff.

The Politics of Apolitical Culture: The Congress for Cultural Freedom,the CIA & Post-War American Hegemony (Routledge Psa Political Studies Series, 2)

This e-book analyses a key episode within the cultural chilly warfare - the formation of the Congress for Cultural Freedom. when the Congress was once proven to protect cultural values and freedom of expression within the chilly conflict fight, its shut organization with the CIA later undermined its claims to highbrow independence or non-political autonomy.

Extra resources for American Idyll: Academic Antielitism as Cultural Critique

Sample text

For Gould, scientific racism was spurred on by the election of Richard Nixon and the fears of social disorder following a decade of civil unrest. 33 In fact, Herrnstein’s arguments blithely echoed Young’s satire of meritocratic rhetoric. Aristocracy, for Herrnstein, was incapable of rewarding the biologically superior members of a society. That was why there were revolutions and revolts. For him, the present system of social triage had produced inevitable natural stratifications. Ironically, this came about because “society” had removed “artificial barriers” between classes, allowing biological ones to replace them.

8 In progressive thinking, education became deeply invested as an “efficient” means for solving social problems, resolving social contradictions, and bringing about an end to inequality or even transforming the sensibilities that would tolerate inequality. In fact, Dewey seemed to suggest that children, guided by the correct methods of supportive noninterference, would learn to participate in “necessary collective efforts” and that laissez-faire individualism would meet its end in the pragmatically oriented, socially enlightened classroom.

Founded in 1947, ETS played a critical role in the transformation of American higher education after World War II: as universities and student populations exploded, the efficient management of educational resources and opportunities became increasingly important. ETS provided the standardized test as a critical instrument in evaluating and assessing diverse new populations of students for whom higher education had become a possibility but not a right or an entitlement. Furthermore, the equitable distribution of these resources would demonstrate the fundamentally democratic ethos of postwar American society itself.

Download PDF sample

Rated 4.26 of 5 – based on 41 votes